skip to main content skip to footer


I love the food. Wonderful customer service ... read more
Shanika Handy via - Feb 23, 2021
FANTASTIC! Service...was wonderful! Place was cozy and warm.The food was reasonably priced and delicious! Can't say enough how great it was! Top shelf! A true gem in Pittsville!!
fran Grote via - Feb 6, 2021
Its a great place, wonderful food. And the people are awesome. Its a most eat place.
Janet Phillips via - Jan 12, 2021
The Boxcar burger was really tasty. Oh try the lemon berry cake, amazing, so fresh!
Wh Pooh via - Jan 3, 2021
Food was delicious!
Denise Chamberlain via - Jan 1, 2021
We had carry out and the food was so good! Fried green crabby tomatoes! Yummy!!
Corleen Reeling via - Dec 18, 2020
It was good food and drinks ... read more
Justin Daisey via - Dec 18, 2020
You'll LOVE this place!! Food is outstanding! Customer service is to notch!! Paul and John know how to take care is their customers. Give Boxcar 40 a try, and I guarantee you'll return!
Ellen via - Nov 9, 2020
The burgers were good but part of our order was missing and the fries weren't what I had expected from what I had seen online.
Roberta Burke via - Nov 7, 2020
We had a great time John the GM was awesome, food was delicious and they were covid compliant, thank you for a memorable experience.
Carlos Mir via - Nov 5, 2020
Food was amazing, deviled eggs were the best I’ve ever had, service was great, the outdoor dining was closed because of the weather so we ate inside but felt that the distancing & COVID precautions were very good.
Kaitlyn Donaldson via - Oct 31, 2020
I usually don't start out with this, but the service was excellent! The food had interesting combinations and additions but all were pretty good. We had pork ribs and steak. Both were prepared very well.
Ghee Buttersnaps via - Oct 30, 2020
Nice atmosphere. Great service. Good food!!!!
Whitney Cook via - Oct 24, 2020
Cynthia Cobai via - Oct 23, 2020
Another great meal at Boxcar 40!! Special Birthday dinner for me!! Fabulous food, Wonderful service and a slice of lemon blueberry cake to die for!! A real treat. We wish you much sucess!
Jody Hagler via - Oct 19, 2020
Excellent food and service ... read more
Daddo Smith via - Oct 14, 2020
Great food ... read more
Clinton Foskey via - Sep 29, 2020
Food and service was great.
Bradley Quillen via - Sep 26, 2020
Update: upgraded to 5/5. It's the perfect locals spot, friendly staff who remember you and the food is perfect every. single. time Phenomenal presentation and a great price for this amazing food. Rating will PROBABLY go to a 5 after I try this place one more time ... read more
Mary Bohn via - Sep 26, 2020
Found this spot during our Adventure Challenge! Crabby Pretzels are a must-have! Brisket Grilled Cheese was good & filling! Lots of options for the Boxcar Burger! Our waitress was super sweet! Decor inside and out is on point! Hope to make my way back here soon!
Sonji Hubbard via - Sep 23, 2020
Amazing little place. Very cool atmosphere in an old firehouse. Friendly staff and food was great.
Stephen M via - Sep 16, 2020
Great place, off the beaten path & very good food. I had crabcake sandwich, was very good. Also try the deviled eggs! Can't wait to go again 🙂 ... read more
Nana Banana via - Sep 12, 2020
Deviled eggs were so good. Shrimp and grits were to die for.
Nikki Hayes via - Sep 9, 2020
Good food, good drinks. Nice atmosphere ... read more
Joed Mejber via - Aug 29, 2020
Always excellent food and staff! Highly recommend!
Denise Williams via - Aug 22, 2020
Fantastic. Brisket was a little dry but the three dipping sauces made up for it. Pork belly was tender as could be. Mac and cheese appetizer with brisket was enough for my fiance as a meal. Highly recommend. So ready to go back and try more stuff. Staff was very friendly and laid back.
Ryan Payne via - Aug 21, 2020
Phenomenal presentation and a great price for this amazing food. Rating will PROBABLY go to a 5 after I try this place one more time ... read more
Mary Bohn via - Jul 31, 2020
Thank you for letting patrons know your status. Can't wait for you to reopen ... read more
Sunny Sonnenrein via - Jul 5, 2020
Fabulous food, fantastic service, and great company. Great 1st dining out since Covid-19 for this group. Thank you!
tanja giles via - Jul 2, 2020
Dude I just called yall! This was literally THE BEST food experience I've had locally in years!!! AND CARRY OUT AT THAT! The order was done in perfect time , It stayed hot the whole time until I got home to eat it , and dear jesus or who ever yall pray to.....the brisket...... that was some of the most perfectly cooked brisket. ... read more
Joey Glenn via - Jun 18, 2020
Amazing bbq!
john meister via - Mar 15, 2020
Great service, great food and a wonderful atmosphere. Will definitely come back. I just loved everything about this restaurant ♡ ... read more
Angela Mckenna via - Mar 14, 2020
Food is delicious! Definetly worth the trip! The Brownie Sundae was amazing! The brussel sprouts were delicious with blue cheese!
Brenda Carey via - Mar 7, 2020
Great food and service ... read more
Tom Heck via - Feb 29, 2020
Top notch bbq. Crust on most pieces. Also risotto was extra creamy with perfectly prepared scallops ... read more
Seth Underwood via - Feb 29, 2020
Amazing burgers!
Aaron Calloway via - Feb 27, 2020
Some of the best ribs, brisquit and grits on the shore.
mike marshall via - Feb 26, 2020
Novel location and menu
Five for Saturday dinner. Choices ranged from filet mignon, shrimp and grits, fried green tomatoes, burger and pork ribs. Sides are a little small and the menu seems to be priced a littlte high. Service was a little slow. There was a larger party in...More ... read more
OceanCityJoe via - Feb 13, 2020
Friendly staff but not pushy or fake...small town feel but not dinner was good but maybe brisket was slightly dry and filet slightly over done.... interesting interior.....will likely try again ... read more
Jason Sapp via - Feb 10, 2020
Cute place especially for the area. The filet mignon was waaaaay over cooked, Asked for it medium, was well done and a bit charred on the outside but the taste itself was fantastic.
M M Phoenix via - Feb 8, 2020
Tasty, and atmospheric!
Jordan Wharton via - Feb 2, 2020
It was great... bartender was very accommodating and food was delicious!
Roberta Hoch via - Jan 25, 2020
Excellent! And a great server!!
Mary Hager via - Jan 6, 2020
First visit early tonight - 01/04/20 We enjoyed delicious food, generous portions of our burgers, salads, and soup - we took home 1/2 for later. Nice woody "rustic chic" decor. Even though almost full, it wasn't too loud to keep a good conversation going at our table. We will be back for entrees next time (on a tight snack size budge ... read more
Catie Shingleton via - Jan 5, 2020
Yummy Yummy!
First visit early tonight. We enjoyed delicious food, generous portions of our burgers, salads, and soup - we took home 1/2 for later. Nice woody "rustic chic" decor. Even though almost full, it wasn't too loud to keep a good conversation going at our table....More ... read more
DorothyMcG via - Jan 4, 2020
Great food. Celebrated my 10# weight loss with a little splurge. So with it ... read more
Stephanie Tupper via - Dec 29, 2019
Awesome place to eat. Try the brisket mac n cheese!
PAM RHOADS via - Dec 28, 2019
Sharing a meal with friends
Thoroughly enjoyed my meal with friends and family. Shrimp and grits, blackened tuna and crab cake were all “I would order again” quality. Not sure the crabby pretzel was crabby enough, but still tasty and and Italian lemon cake was delish! Best of all- excellent...More ... read more
miamimimi2016 via - Dec 22, 2019
Food was amazing. Crab cakes to die for. Fried green tomatoes amazing. My husband raved about the burger. I had two wonderful orange crushes ... read more
Barbara Ogurcak via - Dec 18, 2019
Great food as always ... read more
Lynn Bragg via - Dec 15, 2019
Love the atmosphere and food! Food is pretty pricey but worth it once ina while.
George via - Dec 13, 2019
I love this place! Tucked out of the way, but easy to access. Great brick walls and overall atmosphere. It’s a great blend of traditional pub with a twist and a few upscale offerings from a great chef. My one stop shop in Ocean City!
Gaill Thompson via - Dec 10, 2019
Nice clean friendly atmosphere with good food and live entertainment ... read more
Ed Skiba via - Nov 30, 2019
A great local's place. Great burgers, loved the fried pickles.
Susan Mills via - Nov 25, 2019
Always the best food & service around.
Beth R via - Nov 21, 2019
Food and service was excellent. My first time eating here. Was not disappointed ... read more
Shelia Scarborough via - Nov 17, 2019
Great menu and atmosphere. Use to be a firehouse. Food is really delicious.
Patricia Gerrity via - Nov 1, 2019
Cozy and Fun
Quiet mid week night with few people. Nice quality food and service in a homey atmosphere. Small town cafe right off route 50 on your way to the beach.
mikeywwes via - Oct 8, 2019
Went for Sunday NFL football. Upstairs bar was great. Plenty of TVs and wasn't overly crowded (although it is a Steelers fan club bar so it is crowded when Steelers are playing). Great beer specials and food was good too.
Mark Swift via - Oct 2, 2019
Awesome food!
Aaron Collins via - Sep 29, 2019
Such an incredible place. And with a gluten free family it is so nice to have an incredibly experienced chef and staff that know what they are talking about. Highly recommend!!!! One of the best I have ever been to in the USA!
Chris McCabe via - Sep 28, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire